Best and worst UI for subway ticket system

June 20, 2013

Read time 1 min

Case 1: Singapore

  1. Click your destination directly from the subway map (Outram Park)
  2. Insert coins until price is zero
  3. Take the ticket

Case 2: San Francisco

  1. Select payment method (Credit card)
  2. Find your stop from subway map
  3. Find your stop from a list (Montgomery)
  4. Look for one way price and remember it ($1,75)
  5. Calculate how many full integers can be subtracted from 20
  6. Click Subtract $1 for 18 times
  7. Calculate how many 0.05 decimals can be subtracted from 2
  8. Click Subtract 5 cent for 5 times
  9. Click Print $1.75 ticket
  10. Click to confirm
  11. Take the ticket

Comparison

Case 1 required 1 click when case 2 required 26 clicks plus some math, searching from a list and keeping numbers in mind. Is it that hard to simulate most typical use cases before implementing them?

Sign up for our newsletter

Get the latest from us in tech, business, design – and why not life.